Precision and accuracy are very important in engineering, and axial runout is one of the most common ways that mistakes happen when machining.
Axial runout is the amount that a cutting tool's axis of rotation is off from a plane.
This can have a big effect on the accuracy of the finished product, which can lead to expensive rework, more waste, and less efficiency.
Understanding axial runout is important for engineering students and professionals who want to make sure that machining works well and stays precise.
In this blog post, I will talk about the causes and effects of axial runout, talk about how to measure it, and look at the best ways to keep its effects on machining operations to a minimum.
So, whether you are an experienced engineer or a curious student, buckle up and get ready to learn about the fascinating world of axial runout.
Introduction to Axial Runout
Formal definition:
The total amount along the axis of rotation by which the rotation of a cutting tool deviates from a plane.
Axial runout is a type of runout that describes how far a cutting tool's axis of rotation is from a plane.
It happens when the axis of rotation is not the same as the spindle's central axis, and the difference is measured along the axis of rotation.
On the other hand, radial runout happens when the axis of rotation moves away from the spindle's centerline axis but stays parallel to it.
Both kinds of runout can cause problems like vibration, noise, and a loss of accuracy.
Radial vs. Axial Runout
Along the length of the centerline axis, the amount of radial runout is always the same, but the amount of axial runout changes depending on where it is measured in relation to the base.
A surface's position when it rotates in a vertical plane is affected by its axial runout.
Its radial runout, on the other hand, describes how round or off-center it is.
Usually, rotary stages and tables are made with both radial and axial runouts.
Measurement of Axial Runout
Axial runout is the angle between two axes that are not in the same plane.
In this case, the difference between a part and a reference axis grows as you move away from where they meet.
A dial indicator is put on the spindle of the rotary table or stage to measure axial runout.
The indicator is then moved so that it touches the reference surface, and the table is turned to find out how far it can be from the reference plane.
Tip: Turn on the caption button if you need it. Choose “automatic translation” in the settings button, if you are not familiar with the English language. You may need to click on the language of the video first before your favorite language becomes available for translation.
Causes and Effects of Axial Runout
Some of the things that can cause axial runout are worn or misaligned bearings, a bent spindle or workpiece, sloppy tool or fixture alignment, and the machine tool expanding as it heats up.
If axial runout is not taken into account or is not fixed during machining, it can cause the part to be less accurate, parts to be rejected, costs to go up, and productivity to go down.
Effects of Axial Runout
Axial runout can affect machining operations by making the chip load uneven or causing the tool to chatter too much.
This can cause the tip to move, which changes the way the surface is made and how rough it is.
It can also cause changes in the surface's topography.
For example, if the value is high enough, the distance between tool marks can change, and the tool mark left by the kth tooth can be removed.
Also, axial runout changes where the cutting tool is in the vertical plane, which can cause uneven chip loads, shorter tool life, and more vibration.
This, in turn, can cause the workpiece's surface to have a bad finish, such as roughness, waves, and chatter marks.
When machining along the Z-axis, axial runout can also change the depth of cut and lead to errors in dimensions, such as taper.
When delicate or high-precision parts are being machined, the effects of axial runout on surface finish can be very noticeable.
Radial Runout
On the other hand, radial runout happens when the axis of rotation moves away from the spindle's centerline axis but stays parallel to it.
Both kinds of runout can make a tool or piece of equipment less accurate, which can make it spin off its ideal axis.
Radial runout makes it harder to center a part on the table, which can lead to an angle error that is too big to be acceptable.
Radial and axial runouts can cause cutting tools to wear out too quickly or unevenly, which can cause them to break too soon and make the process less secure.
Such breaks could make it harder to recondition or use the remaining cutting edges, which would raise the cost of consumables.
Runout has a big effect on how accurate machining is and how long tools last.
Measurement of Axial Runout
There are different ways to measure axial runout that vary in how accurate they are and how hard they are to use.
Static Testing Methods
Static testing is a common way to measure axial runout because it is easier and costs less than dynamic testing.
Static tests are done when the spindle or workpiece is still.
There are different ways to do them, which are explained in the Axes of Rotation by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
A dial indicator with a standard magnetic base is a simple and common way to measure the runout of a coupling or a shaft.
To do this test, the magnetic base is put on a flat surface near the coupling or shaft, and the dial indicator is put on the coupling or shaft to measure the runout.
If there is too much runout, it means that the inner diameter of the coupling hub is worn or that the shaft is bent.
In some cases, it is also a good idea to check the coupling's axial runout by putting the dial indicator on the coupling hub's outer face.
Dynamic Testing Methods
Dynamic testing methods are harder to understand, but they give slightly more accurate results because they take heat, vibration, and centrifugal force into account.
Dynamic testing is done while the spindle or workpiece is moving.
It can also be done in different ways, such as using the time-based or frequency-based methods.
In the time-based method, a tachometer is used to measure how fast the spindle is turning and an accelerometer is used to measure how much runout is causing the machine to shake.
The frequency-based method measures the frequency of the vibrations caused by runout with a frequency analyzer.
Equipment and Calibration
The accuracy of measurements of axial runout depends on the equipment used and how it is set up and calibrated.
No matter what method is used, accurate measurements need to be set up and calibrated correctly.
It is important to make sure the equipment is set up and calibrated correctly so that it can give accurate readings.
Shaft Runout
Most of the time, axial shaft runout is used to check the condition of thrust bearings.
It is measured at the shaft's middle (on its rotary axis).
Face runout is the term for measurements that are not in the center.
In this case, flatness and squareness become part of the measurement, which most applications do not care about.
Radial shaft runout is a way to measure how much a round shaft moves around its center as it turns.
Drive/shaft alignment, bearing stiffness, increasing runout as bearings wear, and balance are all things that can cause this.
Difference between Axial and Radial Runout
Both types of runout are deviations from the intended axis of rotation, but the direction of the deviation and the effects on the workpiece are different for each type.
Radial Runout Explained
Radial runout is when the axis of rotation is not in line with the spindle's centerline but is still off from it.
Radial runout is a measurement that is the same all the way along the machine's axis.
It shows how a rotary table moves when it turns in a horizontal plane.
It is sometimes called eccentricity or lateral translation.
Axial Runout Explained
When a cutting tool's axis of rotation moves away from a plane along its axis of rotation, this is called axial runout.
Because of the deviation, the axis is now tilted and no longer runs parallel to the main axis.
How much axial runout there is will depend on where on the base it is measured.
Axial runout can lead to a number of problems, such as uneven chip load, too much tool chatter, tip drift, and problems with surface roughness and generation.
Effects of Radial and Axial Runout
Both kinds of runout can make a tool or piece of equipment less accurate, which can make it spin off its ideal axis.
Radial runout makes it harder to center a part on a table, which leads to angular errors and poor surface finish in the form of roundness errors.
Axial runout changes where the cutting tool is in the vertical plane, which causes uneven chip loads, shorter tool life, and more vibration.
This, in turn, can cause the workpiece's surface to have a bad finish, such as roughness, waves, and chatter marks.
When machining along the Z-axis, axial runout can also change the depth of cut and lead to errors in dimensions, such as taper.
Measuring Axial and Radial Runout
Most of the time, a dial indicator with a standard magnetic base is used to measure the runout of a coupling or shaft.
Just put the magnetic base on a flat surface close to the shaft or coupling.
Then, put the dial indicator on the coupling or shaft and watch how the dial moves.
If there is too much runout, it means that the inner diameter of the coupling hub is worn or that the shaft is bent.
In some cases, it is also a good idea to check the coupling's axial runout by putting the dial indicator on the coupling hub's outer face.
Axial runout can be measured in a number of ways.
Dial indicators, laser sensors, and coordinate measuring machines are some of the most common ways to do this.
Simple measurements are often made with dial indicators, like those with a magnetic base.
The test is done by putting the magnetic base on a flat surface and putting the dial indicator on the shaft or coupling to measure the runout.
Laser sensors or coordinate measuring machines can be used to make measurements that are more exact and precise.
These devices let you take measurements without touching them, and they can measure runout along more than one axis at the same time.
Minimizing and Eliminating Axial Runout
To reduce or get rid of axial runout, it is important to set up and maintain the machine correctly.
Here are some of the best ways to reduce axial runout:
- Precision tool holders: Using precision tool holders like shrink-fit or press-fit tool holders can give you accurate and precise tool rotation, which can help reduce runout.
- Choosing machines and tool holders with minimal runout: Choosing machines and tool holders with minimal runout is key to keeping the total runout of a system to a minimum.
- Uniform pressure: Make sure there is the same amount of pressure all around the shank to reduce runout.
- Checking and replacing worn bearings: To reduce axial runout, worn or damaged bearings should be checked and replaced on a regular basis.
- Monitoring and controlling cutting forces: Using the right cutting parameters, for example, can help control cutting forces and reduce axial runout.
Industry Standards and Specifications
There are industry standards and specifications for axial runout that are used to make sure that parts meet certain accuracy and precision requirements.
Organizations like the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the American National Standards Institute set these rules and requirements (ANSI).
Circular runout is one of the most often used industry standards for axial runout.
Circular runout is a type of geometric tolerance that is used to measure how much a surface moves up or down as it turns in a horizontal plane.
In circular runout, the datum axis is used as a point of reference for the tolerance zone.
This makes a 2D tolerance zone around the datum axis.
To meet the callout, all points on the real surface must be inside this tolerance zone.
By combining two short axes at the ends of the part, circular runout can also be used to check other central part features.
There are other rules in the business world about axial runout, such as:
- ISO 1101: This standard describes the general requirements for geometric tolerancing of workpieces, including the use of tolerance zones to control shape, orientation, and location.
This standard, ANSI Y14.5, says how geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T) must be used on engineering drawings.
This standard, ASME B89.3.4, says how to measure axial runout with dial indicators or electronic displacement probes.
These industry standards and specifications give engineers, manufacturers, and people in charge of quality control a way to talk to each other and make sure that parts meet certain requirements.
By following these standards and guidelines, manufacturers can make sure that their parts are accurate and meet their customers' needs.
Conclusion
In conclusion, axial runout is an important thing for engineers and machinists to think about if they want their work to be precise.
It is always a threat to the accuracy and efficiency of machining operations, but with the right tools, techniques, and knowledge, it can be dealt with.
By understanding the causes and effects of axial runout and using best practices to reduce its effects, engineering professionals can achieve high levels of accuracy, improve productivity, and reduce waste.
But axial runout is also a reminder of the delicate balance that needs to be kept between the complexity of making things and the desire for perfection.
As we keep coming up with new ideas and pushing the limits of what is possible, we need to stay humble in the face of challenges and always try to learn more about and get better at the world around us.
Share on…
